I was wondering whether a water molecule exhibits the intermediate axis theorem (IAT) effect.

I was also curious if a tool like MapleSim could be used for simulations, as it is designed with technical applications in mind. (It would have been handy to enter parameters in Angstroms and atomic mass, but MapleSim only provides length in mm and mass in grams for small objects.)  

The atoms of the H2O molecule form an obtuse triangle. An obtuse triangle exhibits the effect when rotated about its intermediate axis (horizontal axis in the image below) provided it consists of equal point masses (more details here) which is not the case for oxygen and hydrogen. 

Building and running a model is quick since geometry and masses are available online. Two molecules are modeled in the attached file with parameters from different sources. The left model in the image below represents the atoms as three discrete point masses without individual rotational inertia. The system's total inertia is derived entirely from the spatial distribution of these masses. On the right, the entire molecule is modeled as a single lumped mass located at the center of mass (CoM), with the molecule’s full rotational inertia tensor applied at that point.

IAT_H2O.msim

Both models are rotating about the assumed intermediate axis at 3 THz (3 trillion rotations per second), which is about two orders of magnitude less than near-infrared light (just beyond the visible spectrum). To generate the IAT effect an orthogonal tiny initial “kick” of 0.001 Hz was added.

Visualizing was not so easy since the models are in the picometer range. It was difficult to locate the molecules by zooming with the mouse wheel (the button “Fit scene” on the 3-D Playback window did not work). Running an animation to visualize the IAT effect was not possible because the display speed could “only” be slowed down by a factor of 2^31 (see A in the image below). However, the slider C to move back and forth in time worked. The time (B) was always rounded to zero due to the very short simulation time span of 1E-10 seconds (i.e. 10 picoseconds).

Export of an animation movie worked better. Over the displayed timespan of 10 ps the molecules flip 2 times back and forth. This corresponds to a flip frequency of 200 GHz.

Time is still not displayed in the movie but that is pretty much all what did not work. Overall, a good performance. Also the numerical results did not show signs of loss of fidelity despite the atomic scale  of the objects and the very short time span.

In reality, the rotation of a dipole results in the emission of electromagnetic radiation, which dissipates energy and decelerates the molecule. How can this damping effect be modeled in MapleSim? Someone has an idea?


Please Wait...