nm

11993 Reputation

20 Badges

13 years, 191 days

MaplePrimes Activity


These are replies submitted by nm

How did you generate the bode plot? You need transfer function to generate bode plot?

restart: 
alias(DS=DynamicSystems): 
sys:=DS:-TransferFunction(5*s/(s^2+4*s+25)): 
DS:-BodePlot(sys,output=dualaxis, range=0.1..100);

so you already has the TS. Even if you have state space, you can convert that to TF.

 

how to find CharacteristicPolynomiall of matrix with vector entries?

I do not understand what the issue is. Why not just do something like

V1:=Vector[column]([1,2,3]);
V2:=Vector[column]([4,7,9]);
V3:=Vector[column]([99,8,11]);
M:=Matrix([V1,V2,V3]);
LinearAlgebra:-CharacteristicPolynomial(M,x)

It works for me on Maple 2023.2

@Christian Wolinski 

I am interested to learn how  then you interpret the help page saying

    "It will do the simultaneous substitutions specified by the eqi equation arguments in the last argument expr"

Would that not imply all substitutions are done in place and at same time on the original expression? This is how I read it.

Ofcourse, the help page could be wrong and internally it does as you described. I do not know.

@Carl Love 

opps, you are right. I forgot this rule. So maple's Math is the correct one.  I need to go have more coeffee.

@Christian Wolinski 

I thought that is what it did, this is why I asked if order matters. But that would be really wrong design if this was the case. Also help says

And dictionary says  that simultaneous means:  occurring, operating, or done at the same time.

So it should be doing the substitution in "batch mode", ie, at same time. Not do one. Evaluate the new expression, and now do the next replacement on the new expression, which ofcourse could now have changed, reshuffled, order of operands might change, number of operands changed, and so on. This design would make no sense from the user point of view if this was the case, right?

But who knows. May be help is wrong and may be it works as you said.

fyi, this gives zero

VectorCalculus:-Laplacian(1/r, 'spherical'[r,phi,theta] )

                         0

@Preben Alsholm 

Thanks. But I am little confused what is the bottom line here. Is this a bug in has?

But if one wants to write a function that takes in P, where P is the plot generated by DEplot, and return true of false depending if the plot is empty or not, then what will this function looks like based on what you found above?

@sursumCorda 

are all allowed

Not on V Maple 2023.2. The last fails.

 

I looked for this sometime ago, and could not find one. Yes, it will be nice to be able to do the same as Matlab. But nothing like ~ exist in Maple as far as I know.

@Carl Love 

Thanks. That is good to know. I had no idea that subs will do it, as I use eval() all the time to replace symbols in expression.

It seems because subs does not do evaluation it worked in this case. It is really hard sometimes to figure out when to use eval and when to use subs when one wants to replace things in an expression. But in this example, will use subs then.

@Carl Love 

Yes, I understand why it failed when using curved. I knew it is because it did something different that when the arrow is not curved.

But this is really beside the point. These are internal detailes the user of the software should not care about.

When I write a function that takes two options, and it fails when using option 1 but does not fail when using option 2, then this  is a fault of my function. Not the user for using wrong input.

Software should be robust and not fail like this. For example, if Maple is not able to do it internally using curve arrow for some cases, it should internally handle this. May be not process the curve at that location and leave it empty and go on to the next location. Or may be do something else.

But it should not give an exception.  

 

@Carl Love 

Please see what I wrote above about it failng ONLY when using 'arrows'='curve'. My code works fine using y = -1.6 .. 1.6 when not using the option arrows = 'curve'. That is the whole point of what I am asking.

restart;
ode := diff(y(x), x) - 1/(-x^2 + 1)^(1/2) = 0;
x_range := -0.99 .. 0.99;
DEtools:-DEplot(ode, y(x), x = x_range, y = -1.6 .. 1.6, [y(0) = 0]);

works fine.

restart;
ode := diff(y(x), x) - 1/(-x^2 + 1)^(1/2) = 0;
x_range := -0.99 .. 0.99;
DEtools:-DEplot(ode, y(x), x = x_range, y = -1.6 .. 1.6, [y(0) = 0],arrows = 'curve');

error

So I expect the software to not fail when using arrows = 'curve'

@sursumCorda 

Yes, VectorPlot in Mathematica might be closer to Maple's DEplot. But I was looking for something similar to StreamPlot to make PhasePlot since it looks better than VectorPlot. Using arrow='curve' in Maple's got it a little closer to StreamPlot, but there is a bug with arrow='curve'. 

@C_R 

Yes, I knew that if I change the range randomly the bug will go away. But this is not practical solution. And what will I do for for next 10,000 systems I am processing? Keep trying different ranges each time randomly until I find one that does not crash Maple?

Hopefully Maple will fix this in next version. 

Too many bugs, crashes and hangs in Maple. And it keeps getting worst with each new release.

@Rouben Rostamian  

That is better. I knew about arrowsize=number option and did try before. The problem with this, is that I want to run this code on thousands of systems, and if I hard code it to 1.5, it might look OK for some systems, but might look bad for others.

May be others need arrowsize=1.5 and some need arrowsize=2.0 and so on. I do not know.

It would have been better if Maple had an option to make the lines all connected and put the arrows on them, like with Mathematica's. 

But for now, will try 1.5 and see how it works. The axes=boxed and color='magnitude[legacy]' helped. make it better. thanks.

btw, why on your version the tick labels and the axes labels look bigger and darker than what I get? I am on windows 10, Maple 2023.2. This is what I get

I run your code as is, after restart. It looks like your fonts are different than what I am using. Did you by any chance modify some settings in your Maple before this? Your fonts look better than what I am gettings.

First 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 Last Page 26 of 92